Agm battery vs lead acid

Imagine for a moment that your home is a living, breathing organism. In this analogy, the solar panels on your roof are the eyes, gathering energy from the sun. The inverter is the brain, directing that energy where it needs to go. But the heart? The heart of your solar system is undoubtedly the battery bank. It is the component that pumps life—in the form of electricity—into your lights, your refrigerator, and your internet router when the sun goes down or the grid fails. Without a healthy heart, the rest of the system, no matter how expensive or advanced, is simply potential waiting to happen.
For homeowners across the United States, taking the leap into solar energy is often driven by a desire for independence. You want to cut ties with rising utility rates, ensure your family is safe during blackout seasons, or simply reduce your carbon footprint. However, the dream of energy independence hits a very practical fork in the road when it comes to storing that power. You have to choose a battery. For decades, the standard answer to this problem has been the lead‑acid battery. It is a technology that has been around since the mid‑19th century, reliably starting our cars, powering our golf carts, and keeping the lights on in off‑grid cabins from Maine to Arizona.1
But within the world of lead‑acid batteries, there remains a fierce rivalry between two distinct technologies: the traditional Flooded Lead‑Acid (FLA) battery and the more modern Absorbent Glass Mat (AGM) battery. At a casual glance, they look remarkably similar—heavy, boxy, industrial objects with metal terminals on top. Yet, inside those plastic cases, they are worlds apart. One demands your attention and care, asking you to perform regular maintenance rituals in exchange for longevity and low cost. The other offers a "set it and forget it" experience, promising convenience and safety but asking for a premium price in return.1
This report is designed to be your definitive guide to making that choice. We are not just going to list specifications; we are going to explore what it actually means to live with these batteries day in and day out. We will look at the chemistry that powers them, the maintenance they demand, how they handle the freezing cold of a Minnesota winter or the blistering heat of a Texas summer, and ultimately, which one makes the most financial sense for your wallet. Whether you are building an off‑grid cabin in the woods or backing up a suburban home against storm outages, understanding the heart of your system is the first step toward true energy security.

---

Part 1: The Chemistry of Storage

To understand the difference between AGM and flooded batteries, we first have to understand what makes them similar. They are both members of the lead‑acid family. This isn't just trivia; it explains why they are heavy, why they are recyclable, and why they behave the way they do.

1.1 The Lead‑Acid Legacy

The basic chemistry of a lead‑acid battery has remained largely unchanged for over 150 years because it is robust, reliable, and relatively inexpensive to manufacture. Inside every cell of a lead‑acid battery, you will find alternating plates of lead. The positive plates are coated with lead dioxide, and the negative plates are made of sponge lead. These plates are submerged in an electrolyte solution—a mixture of sulfuric acid and water.3
When you connect a load to the battery, like a lightbulb, a chemical reaction begins. The sulfuric acid molecules break apart. The sulfate part bonds to the lead plates, coating them in lead sulfate. This reaction releases electrons, which flow out of the battery terminals and through your lightbulb, creating electricity. During this process, the acid in the electrolyte is "used up," leaving the solution mostly water.4
When the sun comes up and your solar panels start pushing energy back into the battery, the process reverses. The electricity forces the sulfate to let go of the lead plates and dissolve back into the water, turning it back into strong sulfuric acid. It is a beautiful, reversible cycle. However, the physical structure holding this chemistry together determines everything about the battery's performance and maintenance.4

1.2 The Traditional "Flooded" Design

The flooded lead‑acid battery is the design most people are familiar with. If you picture a classic car battery or a golf cart battery with removable caps on top, you are picturing a flooded battery. They are called "flooded" or "wet cells" because the lead plates are literally swimming in a pool of liquid electrolyte. The liquid flows freely around the plates, allowing for chemical reactions to happen easily.1
This design has several defining characteristics that are crucial for a homeowner to understand:

Venting: Because the liquid is free‑flowing, these batteries are not sealed. They have vents to allow gases to escape. When the battery is charging, the water in the electrolyte can split into hydrogen and oxygen gas. This is a natural byproduct of the charging process, but it means the battery is constantly losing water to the air.1
Access: Because water is lost, you need a way to put it back. Flooded batteries have removable caps that allow you to look inside, check the fluid levels, and top them off with distilled water. This access is both a feature and a chore.2
Orientation: Gravity is the only thing keeping the acid where it belongs. If you tip a flooded battery sideways, the acid will spill out of the vents. This limits how and where you can install them.1

1.3 The AGM Revolution

In the late 20th century, engineers looked for a way to make lead‑acid batteries safer and less demanding. The result was the Absorbent Glass Mat, or AGM, battery. This is part of a broader category called Valve Regulated Lead‑Acid (VRLA) batteries.1
In an AGM battery, the chemistry is the same—lead and sulfuric acid—but the electrolyte is managed differently. Instead of a pool of liquid, the acid is soaked into a fine fiberglass mat. This mat has the consistency of a sponge or a diaper. It is sandwiched tightly between the lead plates.
This seemingly simple change has profound effects:

Immobilized Electrolyte: Because the acid is held in the glass mat, there is no free liquid to slosh around. You could cut an AGM battery in half, and it wouldn't leak. This makes them "spill‑proof" and safe to transport without hazardous material restrictions.1
Internal Recombination: Remember the hydrogen and oxygen gas that escapes from flooded batteries? In an AGM battery, the glass mat allows those gases to travel from the positive plate to the negative plate, where they recombine back into water. The battery essentially recycles its own water. Because of this, it doesn't need to be vented to the outside under normal conditions, and it never needs to be refilled.2
Compression: The glass mats are packed very tightly between the plates. This compression supports the lead plates, making them incredibly resistant to vibration and shock. While a flooded battery's plates might rattle and break on a bumpy road, an AGM battery holds everything firm.6

1.4 Why "Sealed" Doesn't Mean "Air Tight"

It is important to clarify a common misconception. AGM batteries are often called "sealed," but they are not hermetically sealed like a can of soup. They have pressure relief valves. If you accidentally overcharge an AGM battery massively—say, by using a charger setting meant for a different battery type—gas will build up faster than the recombination process can handle. To prevent the battery from swelling or bursting, the valve opens and releases a small "burp" of gas. Once that gas escapes, the water it contained is lost forever. Since you cannot open the battery to add water, this permanently damages the battery’s capacity. This is why proper charging settings are critical for AGM batteries, a topic we will explore in depth later.1

---

Part 2: Installation Logistics – Where Do They Go?

Before you even buy a battery, you have to decide where it is going to live. For many homeowners, the physical constraints of their property make the decision for them. The differences in safety, weight, and ventilation requirements between AGM and flooded batteries are significant.

2.1 The Ventilation Challenge

One of the most significant differences between the two technologies is how they interact with the air in your home. This is strictly governed by safety codes, including the National Electrical Code (NEC), because the gas released by batteries—hydrogen—is explosive at concentrations as low as 4%.8

Flooded Batteries: The Need to Breathe

Flooded batteries are "gassers." During the final stage of charging, known as the absorption phase, and especially during equalization (a maintenance charge), they bubble vigorously. This releases hydrogen gas into the room.

Code Requirements: Because of this off‑gassing, the NEC and fire codes generally prohibit installing flooded batteries in living spaces. You cannot put them in a hallway closet or under your bed. They require a dedicated, ventilated enclosure.
The Battery Box: Most homeowners install flooded batteries in a heavy‑duty plastic box vented to the outdoors. This often involves running PVC piping from the battery box through an exterior wall, sometimes assisted by a small DC fan to actively pull the hydrogen out.1
Location: The best place for flooded batteries is a detached shed, a garage, or a utility room that is separate from the main living area. If you live in a tight urban home or a condo where you cannot easily punch holes in walls for vents, flooded batteries may be practically impossible to install legally and safely.10

AGM Batteries: The Indoor Friendly Option

AGM batteries produce almost no off‑gassing during normal operation. The internal recombination process handles the gas generation, keeping it inside the battery casing.

Installation Flexibility: Because they don't emit explosive gas under normal conditions, AGM batteries do not require the same aggressive ventilation systems. The NEC acknowledges that "sealed" batteries like AGM have different requirements. While you still shouldn't put them in a perfectly airtight box (in case of that emergency venting we discussed), they are safe for basements, utility closets, and garages without specialized exhaust fans.11
No Acid Mist: Flooded batteries can release a fine mist of acid along with the gas, which can corrode nearby metal and wiring. AGM batteries are clean. You don't have to worry about your copper wires turning green or steel racks rusting out just because they are near the battery bank.5

2.2 Physical Space and Weight

Lead is heavy. There is no getting around it. Whether you choose flooded or AGM, you are dealing with dense blocks of metal.

Flooded Footprint: Flooded batteries generally need to be installed in a single layer. You need vertical clearance above them to flip open the caps and pour in water. You cannot stack them directly on top of each other effectively, or put them on a shelf with only an inch of clearance. This means a large bank of flooded batteries can take up a significant amount of floor space.13
AGM Density: Since AGM batteries are maintenance‑free, you can pack them much tighter. You can stack them on shelves with minimal clearance, or even mount them on their sides (though terminals‑up is still preferred). This allows you to fit a powerful energy storage system into a much smaller footprint—a huge advantage for retrofitting solar into an existing garage or basement.1

2.3 The "Corrosion Factor"

There is a subtle maintenance aspect related to installation: corrosion.

Flooded Reality: The acid mist that vents from flooded batteries eventually settles on the top of the battery case and the terminals. Over time, this creates that crusty white or blue powder that eats away at battery cables. Owners of flooded batteries must regularly clean the tops of their batteries with a mixture of baking soda and water to neutralize this acid. If you don't, the corrosion can increase resistance, cause voltage drops, and even overheat connections.5
AGM Cleanliness: AGM batteries stay clean. The terminals rarely corrode because there is no acid mist escaping. This keeps your electrical connections healthier for longer with zero effort. For a homeowner who doesn't want to scrub battery terminals with a toothbrush on a Saturday morning, this is a major "quality of life" feature.5

---

Part 3: The Maintenance Reality

This section is where the rubber meets the road. The single biggest differentiator for the average homeowner is the maintenance requirement. It is the difference between a battery bank that is a "pet" and one that is an "appliance."

3.1 The Ritual of Watering (Flooded Batteries)

Owning a flooded lead‑acid battery bank requires diligence. It is not difficult work, but it is necessary work. If you neglect it, you destroy your investment.

The Process

Every 2 to 4 weeks, depending on how heavily you use the batteries and how hot the weather is, you need to perform a check.

Safety First: You put on safety glasses and rubber gloves. Sulfuric acid is dangerous stuff.
Open the Caps: You pop the caps off every single cell. A standard 6‑volt golf cart battery has 3 cells. If you have a 48‑volt system with 8 batteries, that is 24 individual caps to remove.
Inspect: You look inside with a flashlight. You are looking for the electrolyte level. It needs to be above the tops of the lead plates but below the bottom of the fill well.1
Top Up: If the level is low, you carefully pour in distilled water. You cannot use tap water; the minerals in tap water will poison the battery chemistry and shorten its life. You fill it to the correct mark—not too full, or it will overflow when it charges, and not too low, or the plates will dry out.
Close Up: You replace all the caps and wipe down the battery tops.

The Consequence of Neglect

What happens if you forget? If the water level drops below the top of the lead plates, the exposed lead reacts with oxygen in the air. It hardens and oxidizes permanently. You cannot "fix" this by adding water later. That portion of the plate is dead forever, reducing the battery's capacity. If you let it go too long, the battery will simply fail.1

The Vacation Home Problem

This maintenance requirement makes flooded batteries a poor choice for vacation homes that sit empty for months. If you leave a flooded battery bank charging on solar for 4 months while you are away, the water will slowly boil off. You might return to a ruined system. You would need to hire a caretaker just to water your batteries.10

3.2 The "Invisible" Battery (AGM)

AGM batteries are marketed as "maintenance‑free," and for the homeowner, they truly are.

No Access: The battery is sealed. There are no caps to remove. You couldn't add water even if you wanted to.
No Chores: You never have to check fluid levels. You never have to buy jugs of distilled water. You never have to scrub corrosion off the terminals.
Peace of Mind: For a remote cabin or a backup system, this is invaluable. You can leave the system alone for months (provided it has a proper charge controller keeping it topped up), and it will be fine. You don't have to worry about whether you remembered to water the batteries before you locked up for the winter.2

Insight: While "maintenance‑free" is a huge advantage, it has a hidden downside. With flooded batteries, the monthly watering forces you to look at your batteries. You might notice a loose cable, a bulging case, or a weird smell. With AGM, because you never have to look at them, it is easy to ignore them completely until the day they stop working. It is still a good idea to visually inspect AGM batteries a few times a year, even if you don't have to open them.

---

Part 4: Performance Comparison – Power and Efficiency

You might think that because flooded batteries are older technology, they perform worse. That isn't entirely true. In some metrics, they are robust workhorses. But AGM technology brings specific performance advantages that matter for modern homes.

4.1 Internal Resistance and Surge Power

Think of a battery like a water tank. The pipe coming out of the tank determines how fast you can get water out. In a battery, "internal resistance" is the restriction in that pipe.

AGM Advantage: AGM batteries have extremely low internal resistance. The tight packing of the glass mats and the plates creates a very efficient path for electricity. This means they can deliver massive bursts of power instantly. If you are trying to start a large well pump, a central air conditioner, or a table saw, these appliances demand a huge "surge" of current for a split second. AGM batteries handle this surge effortlessly without the voltage dropping (sagging).7
Flooded Limitation: Flooded batteries have higher internal resistance. Under a massive surge load, their voltage can sag significantly. If the voltage drops too low, your solar inverter might panic and shut down to protect itself, causing the lights to go out even though the battery still has charge.2

4.2 Charging Efficiency

This is a crucial metric for off‑grid solar. When you capture energy from the sun, you want to keep as much of it as possible.

The Flooded Tax: Flooded batteries are roughly 80‑85% efficient. This means for every 100 amp‑hours of sunlight you put in, you only get about 80‑85 amp‑hours back. The missing 15‑20% is lost as heat and gas bubbles during the charging process. If you have a small solar array, losing 20% of your production is a painful "tax".17
The AGM Savings: AGM batteries are much more efficient, typically around 95%. They waste very little energy. This means your battery bank charges faster and utilizes your solar panels more effectively. In the depths of winter, when you might only get 3 hours of good sun, capturing 95% of that energy versus 80% can make the difference between having lights that night or running the generator.2

4.3 Self‑Discharge Rates

All batteries lose charge when they are just sitting on a shelf disconnected. This is called self‑discharge.

Flooded Leakage: Flooded batteries are "leaky" when it comes to holding a charge. They lose about 5‑15% of their charge per month just sitting there. If you leave a fully charged flooded battery in an unheated cabin in October and come back in April, it will be dead flat (and probably frozen and ruined).3
AGM Stability: AGM batteries are incredibly stable. They lose only 1‑3% per month. You can charge an AGM battery, disconnect it, leave it for 6 months, and come back to find it still at 80‑90% charge. This makes AGM the undisputed king for seasonal properties or emergency backup systems that sit idle for long periods.2

4.4 Depth of Discharge (DoD)

This is the measure of how much energy you take out of the battery. 100% DoD means you drained it completely flat. 50% DoD means you used half.

The 50% Rule: For almost all lead‑acid batteries, both AGM and flooded, the golden rule is do not discharge deeper than 50%. If you regularly drain them to 80% or 90% DoD, you will drastically shorten their life. While lithium batteries can handle 100% discharge, lead‑acid chemistry suffers when deeply drained.14
Nuance: Some high‑end AGM batteries (like the Trojan AES or carbon‑enhanced models) claim to handle deeper discharges (up to 80% or even 100%) better than standard flooded batteries, but generally, sticking to the 50% rule is the safest way to protect your investment regardless of the type you choose.22

---

Part 5: The Climate Factor – Winter and Summer

Unless you live in a climate‑controlled laboratory, your batteries are going to experience weather. Temperature has a massive impact on lead‑acid chemistry.

5.1 The Cold Reality

Cold weather slows down chemical reactions. This is why your car struggles to start on a frosty morning.

Capacity Loss: As the temperature drops, the available capacity of a lead‑acid battery shrinks. At 32°F (0°C), a battery might only have 70‑80% of its rated capacity. At -20°F (-29°C), it might have less than 50%. This applies to both types, but AGM handles it slightly better due to lower internal resistance.23
The Freezing Risk (Flooded): The electrolyte in a flooded battery is water and acid. As the battery discharges, the acid turns into lead sulfate on the plates, leaving mostly water behind. Water freezes. If a flooded battery is deeply discharged in freezing weather, the liquid inside turns to ice. This expands and cracks the plastic case. Once the case cracks and the ice melts, the acid leaks out, and the battery is destroyed. A fully charged flooded battery won't freeze until extreme sub‑zero temps, but a dead one can freeze at 20°F.24
AGM Resilience: AGM batteries are much more resistant to freezing damage. Because the electrolyte is absorbed in the glass mat and there is no free liquid to expand violently, they are less likely to crack. Furthermore, their lower internal resistance allows them to deliver current even when very cold. This makes AGM the superior choice for unheated spaces in northern climates.16

5.2 The Heat Hazard

While cold hurts performance, heat hurts longevity. Heat acts as a catalyst, speeding up the chemical corrosion of the lead grids inside the battery.

The Rule of Thumb: For every 15°F (8°C) above the standard 77°F (25°C) operating temperature, the life of a lead‑acid battery is cut in half. A battery rated for 10 years at 77°F might only last 5 years at 92°F.23
Water Loss: In hot weather, flooded batteries evaporate water much faster. You might find yourself needing to water them every week in a hot Arizona garage. If you miss a week, the damage happens fast.
Thermal Runaway: AGM batteries are slightly more susceptible to a phenomenon called "thermal runaway" if charged too aggressively in high heat. Because they are sealed, they can't vent heat as easily as flooded batteries. However, modern high‑quality AGM batteries are designed to withstand this better than older models. Generally, keeping any battery cool is key to long life.15

---

Part 6: Lifespan and Longevity

How long will they last? This is the question every homeowner asks. The answer is complicated because it depends on "cycle life"—how many times you can drain and recharge the battery.

6.1 Understanding Cycle Life Data

Manufacturers test batteries in labs and publish charts showing how many cycles a battery can survive at different Depths of Discharge (DoD).

Trojan T‑105 (Flooded Standard): This is the benchmark. It is typically rated for about 1,200 cycles at 50% DoD. If you cycle it every single day, that is about 3.3 years. In a typical solar home where you don't hit 50% every day, a set of T‑105s often lasts 5 to 7 years.29
Standard AGM: Historically, AGM batteries had lower cycle lives, often around 500‑600 cycles at 50% DoD. This led to the reputation that "AGM doesn't last as long".3
Advanced AGM (Trojan AES/Carbon): Technology has moved on. New premium AGM batteries, like the Trojan AES or those with carbon additives, are now claiming cycle lives that equal or exceed flooded batteries—up to 1,200+ cycles at 100% DoD. This is a game‑changer. It means you no longer have to sacrifice longevity to get the convenience of maintenance‑free operation.22

6.2 Real World vs. Lab Data

Here is the critical insight: Flooded batteries only hit their rated lifespan if you maintain them perfectly. If you miss a few watering cycles, or if you chronically undercharge them (causing sulfation), a flooded battery that should last 7 years might die in 2. AGMs, being maintenance‑free, are immune to the "I forgot to water them" failure mode. For many average homeowners who aren't battery hobbyists, an AGM battery bank actually lasts longer in the real world simply because it eliminates human error.

6.3 Table 1: Cycle Life Comparison (Based on Trojan Data)

Battery Model	Technology	Cycle Life @ 50% DoD	Cycle Life @ 100% DoD	Maintenance
Trojan T‑105	Flooded Lead‑Acid	~1,200 Cycles	Not Recommended	High (Watering)
Trojan T‑105 AGM	Standard AGM	~1,000 Cycles	~500 Cycles	None
Trojan T‑105 AES	Advanced AGM	>2,000 Cycles	~1,200 Cycles	None
Rolls S6 L16‑HC	Premium Flooded	~1,850 Cycles	~1,000 Cycles	High (Watering)

---

Part 7: The Economics – Cost vs. Value

This is usually the deciding factor. Is the convenience of AGM worth the price?

7.1 Upfront Cost

Flooded batteries are almost always cheaper to buy initially.

Flooded Cost: A standard 6‑volt golf cart battery (like a Trojan T‑105) typically costs between $150 and $200. For a 48‑volt system requiring 8 batteries, your base cost is around $1,200 – $1,600.22
AGM Cost: A comparable AGM battery generally costs $300 to $450. For that same 8‑battery bank, you are looking at $2,400 – $3,600. That is a significant jump—often double the price.22

7.2 The "Hidden" Costs of Flooded

However, the battery price tag isn't the whole story.

Enclosure Costs: If you buy flooded batteries, you need a safe place to put them. Building a vented battery box, buying PVC vent piping, and installing a DC exhaust fan can easily add $300 – $600 to the installation cost. AGM batteries can sit on a simple rack in the garage.
Maintenance Costs: Distilled water is cheap, but your time is valuable. If you value your time at even a modest hourly rate, the hours spent checking and watering batteries over 5 years adds up.
Generator Fuel: Remember efficiency? Because AGM batteries charge faster and more efficiently (95% vs 80%), you run your backup generator less. If you are off‑grid, saving 15% on your generator fuel bill over 5 years is a substantial amount of money.

7.3 Lifetime Value Scenarios

Scenario A: The Penny Pincher. You have a shed, you are handy, and you check your system every week. You buy flooded batteries. You get 7 years of life out of them. This is the lowest cost per kilowatt‑hour of storage.
Scenario B: The Busy Family. You buy flooded batteries to save money. You install them in the garage (maybe cutting corners on ventilation). You forget to water them during a busy summer. They die in year 3. You have to buy a whole new set. In this case, AGM would have been cheaper in the long run.

Insight: Flooded lead‑acid is the "cheapest" option only if your labor is free and your diligence is perfect. For everyone else, AGM often represents better long‑term value despite the sticker shock.

---

Part 8: Charging Dynamics

One area where homeowners often get confused is how to charge these batteries. You cannot simply hook them up to any charger and walk away. The settings on your solar charge controller or AC charger must match the battery type.

8.1 The Three Stages of Charging

Lead‑acid batteries generally charge in three stages:

Bulk: The charger puts in as much current as possible to bring the voltage up.
Absorption: The charger holds the voltage steady while the current tapers off, slowly filling the last 20% of the battery.
Float: The charger drops the voltage to a "trickle" level just to keep the battery full and counteract self‑discharge.

8.2 Voltage Differences

This is critical.

Flooded Voltages: Flooded batteries generally need higher voltages during the Absorption phase (typically 14.8V for a 12V system). This high voltage causes the bubbling (gassing) that stirs up the acid and prevents stratification (where acid separates from water).
AGM Voltages: AGM batteries need lower voltages (typically 14.1V – 14.4V for a 12V system). If you use the "Flooded" setting on an AGM battery, the high voltage will cause it to gas too aggressively. The valves will pop, the battery will vent water, and it will be permanently damaged. You must set your charge controller to "AGM" or "Sealed."2

8.3 Equalization: The Danger Zone

"Equalization" is a controlled, high‑voltage overcharge (around 15.5V) used periodically on flooded batteries to forcefully mix the acid and clean the plates.

Flooded: You should equalize flooded batteries periodically (e.g., once a month) to keep them healthy.
AGM: You generally NEVER equalize an AGM battery. The high voltage will ruin it. (Note: Some specific high‑end AGM brands like Lifeline allow a specific type of conditioning charge, but for 99% of AGM batteries, equalization is a death sentence).2

---

Part 9: User Scenarios – Which Battery Are You?

We have covered a lot of technical ground. Let's simplify it. Which of these profiles sounds like you?

Profile 1: The Full‑Time Off‑Grid Homesteader

Situation: You live off‑grid year‑round. You rely on solar for everything. You have a dedicated power shed. You watch your system monitors like a hawk.
Recommendation: Premium Flooded Lead‑Acid (e.g., Rolls Surrette L16).
Why: You need massive capacity. You are already committed to the maintenance lifestyle. The lower cost allows you to buy a huge battery bank to survive cloudy weeks. You have the space and ventilation sorted.

Profile 2: The Weekend Cabin Owner

Situation: You have a hunting cabin or lake house. You go there on weekends. In winter, it sits empty and unheated for months.
Recommendation: AGM.
Why: You need a battery that won't self‑discharge and die while you are away. You need a battery that won't freeze if the temp drops. You don't want to spend your Friday night checking acid levels; you want to relax.

Profile 3: The Suburban Backup

Situation: You are connected to the grid, but you want battery backup for storms. You don't have a shed; the equipment has to go in the basement or attached garage.
Recommendation: AGM.
Why: Safety codes likely prohibit flooded batteries in your basement. You need a clean, safe, non‑gassing battery that sits quietly in the corner until the power goes out.

Profile 4: The RV or Van Lifer

Situation: Your "home" moves. You drive down bumpy roads.
Recommendation: AGM.
Why: Vibration resistance is key here. A flooded battery splashing acid around is a safety hazard in a moving vehicle. AGM takes the abuse of the road.

---

Part 10: A Brief Look at Lithium

It is impossible to write this report without addressing the elephant in the room: Lithium‑Iron Phosphate (LiFePO4).

The Comparison: Lithium batteries are lighter, charge even faster than AGM, require zero maintenance, and last 3,000 to 5,000 cycles (vs 500‑1,200 for lead‑acid).
The Cost: They are significantly more expensive upfront than flooded lead‑acid, though prices are dropping and are becoming competitive with high‑end AGM.
The Verdict: If you are looking at premium AGM batteries (like the Trojan AES), you should price‑check Lithium. You might find the cost difference is small enough to make the jump. But if you are looking at budget flooded batteries, Lithium is still in a different price bracket. Lead‑acid remains the king of low barrier‑to‑entry storage.

---

Conclusion

The choice between AGM and Flooded Lead‑Acid batteries is ultimately a trade‑off between money and lifestyle.
Flooded batteries are the budget‑friendly workhorses. They reward the diligent homeowner with long life and low costs. They are perfect for those who have the space for proper ventilation and the discipline for monthly maintenance. They are the "sweat equity" option of the battery world.
AGM batteries are the premium, modern solution. They cost more, but they buy you freedom. Freedom from watering chores, freedom from ventilation anxieties, and freedom from worrying about freezing temperatures. They are safer, cleaner, and faster to charge. For the average homeowner who treats their solar system as an appliance rather than a hobby, AGM is usually the better choice.
As you stand in the aisle (or browse the website) looking at these heavy plastic boxes, ask yourself one honest question: Will I really check the water levels every month?
If the answer is a hesitant "maybe," spend the extra money on AGM. Your future self—sitting in a lit room during a power outage, sipping coffee instead of wrestling with a hydrometer—will thank you.

---

Appendix: Comparison Tables

Table 2: Detailed Feature Comparison

Feature	Flooded Lead‑Acid (FLA)	AGM (Absorbent Glass Mat)
Initial Cost	Low ($)	High ($$)
Maintenance	High (Watering, Cleaning)	None (Maintenance‑Free)
Ventilation	Required (Hydrogen Gas)	Not required for normal use
Spill Risk	High (Upright only)	None (Sealed)
Self‑Discharge	High (5‑15% / month)	Low (1‑3% / month)
Charging Efficiency	~80‑85%	~95%
Freezing Risk	High if discharged	Low
Vibration Resistance	Low	High
Typical Warranty	12‑24 Months	24‑36 Months

Table 3: Technical Specifications (Trojan T‑105 Examples)

Specification	Trojan T‑105 (Flooded)	Trojan T‑105 AGM
Voltage	6V	6V
Capacity (20‑hr)	225 Ah	217 Ah
Weight	62 lbs (28 kg)	68 lbs (31 kg)
Length	10.30 inches	10.30 inches
Height	11.15 inches	10.73 inches
Terminals	Embedded High Profile	M8 / DT
Bulk Charge	14.8V (12V system)	14.1V – 14.4V (12V system)
Float Charge	13.5V (12V system)	13.5V (12V system)
Equalization	Recommended	Prohibited

---

Works cited

Flooded vs Sealed (AGM and Gel) Batteries – Unbound Solar, accessed December 6, 2025, https://unboundsolar.com/blog/lead-acid-battery-comparison
Flooded Batteries vs AGM Batteries: Understanding the Differences – Power‑Sonic, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.power-sonic.com/flooded-batteries-vs-agm-batteries-understanding-the-differences/
Lithium vs. Flooded Lead‑Acid vs. AGM: Which is the Best Battery? – Redodopower, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.redodopower.com/blogs/learn-about-lithium/lithium-vs-lead-acid-vs-agm-battery
Comparing Lead Acid Batteries – Flooded vs. AGM vs. Gel – Ampinvt, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.ampinvt.com/blog/comparing-lead-acid-batteries-flooded-vs-agm-vs-gel/
What is the difference between GEL, AGM and Flooded batteries? – Discover Battery, accessed December 6, 2025, https://discoverbattery.com/support/learning-center/battery-101/what-is-the-difference-between-gel-agm-and-flooded-batteries
AGM vs Flooded Battery, Comprehensive Guide – Wistek, accessed December 6, 2025, https://wis-tek.com/blogs/knowledge/agm-vs-flooded-battery-comprehensive-guide
AGM vs Flooded Battery: Choosing the Right One – Huawei Battery, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.huawei-battery.com/agm-vs-flooded-battery-choosing-the-right-one.html
Tech Note | Battery Room Ventilation Requirements – Eagle Eye Power Solutions, accessed December 6, 2025, https://eepowersolutions.com/resources/tech-notes/battery-room-ventilation-requirements/
Battery Room Ventilation Code Requirements – BHS Industrial Equipment, accessed December 6, 2025, https://na.bhs1.com/blog/post/battery-room-ventilation-code-requirements
Solar newbies–ELI5 the difference between flooded lead‑acid batteries and AGM – Reddit, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/vandwellers/comments/aq6swk/solar_newbieseli5_the_difference_between_flooded/
Demystifying AGM Batteries: Do They Need to be Vented? – ecgsolax, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.ecgsolax.com/blogs/for-beginners/demystifying-agm-batteries-do-they-need-to-be-vented
Myth vs Reality: ESS rooms and ventilation per NEC 706 – Anern Store, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.anernstore.com/blogs/diy-solar-guides/nec-706-ess-room-ventilation-myths
1. Batteries | Caltrans – CA.gov, accessed December 6, 2025, https://dot.ca.gov/programs/equipment/electrical/batteries
AGM vs Flooded Batteries: What You Need to Know – Crownbattery, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.crownbattery.com/news/agm-vs-flooded-batteries-what-you-need-to-know
What to Know About AGM Battery Vs. Lead Acid Battery – AAA, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.acg.aaa.com/connect/blogs/4c/auto/agm-battery-vs-lead-acid-battery
AGM vs. Traditional Batteries: What Makes the Difference? – weize, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.weizeus.com/blogs/weize/agm-vs-traditional-batteries-what-makes-the-difference
AGM vs Flooded. weight & longevity – NAZ Solar Electric Forum, accessed December 6, 2025, https://forum.solar-electric.com/discussion/2753/agm-vs-flooded-weight-amp-longevity
accessed December 6, 2025, https://iotgsolar.com/what-is-charge-efficiency-in-a-battery/#:~:text=Charge%20Efficiency%3A%20Sealed%20AGM%20batteries,batteries%20but%20still%20experience%20losses.
“Charge & Discharge” – St. Petersburg Amateur Radio Club, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.sparc-club.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Batteries-charge-discharge.pdf
AGM Vs Flooded Battery – Which One Should You Choose? – TYCORUN Energy, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.tycorunenergy.com/agm-vs-flooded-battery/
The Expensive Rolls Still a Best Buy in Deep Cycle Batteries – Practical Sailor, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.practical-sailor.com/systems-propulsion/electrical/the-expensive-rolls-still-a-best-buy-in-deep-cycle-batteries
Trojan T105‑AES 6V AGM Battery – Advantage Batteries, accessed December 6, 2025, https://advantagebatteries.com/shop/trojan-t105-aes-6v-agm-battery/
How Does Temperature Affect Battery Performance? – Greentech Renewables, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.greentechrenewables.com/article/how-does-temperature-affect-battery-performance
The Impact of Temperature on Lead‑Acid Battery Performance and Lifespan – Spaceflight Power, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.spaceflightpower.com/the-impact-of-temperature-on-lead-acid/
Which Batteries work better in Winter: AGM, Lead Acid or LiFePO4 – Volts Energies, accessed December 6, 2025, https://volts.ca/blogs/educational/batteries-that-work-best-in-cold-weather
What do I do if I have to store my batteries outside for winter? – Discover Battery, accessed December 6, 2025, https://discoverbattery.com/support/learning-center/battery-101/what-do-i-need-to-store-my-batteries-outside-for-winter
accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.weizeus.com/blogs/weize/agm-vs-traditional-batteries-what-makes-the-difference#:~:text=Cold%20Starts%20and%20Hot%20Summers,power%20when%20it's%20below%20freezing.
AGM vs Lead‑Acid Batteries: Which Performs Better in Cold Weather – Batteries Store, accessed December 6, 2025, https://batteriesstore.ca/blog/battery-5/agm-vs-lead-acid-batteries-which-performs-better-in-cold-weather-109
Trojan Cycle Life Data by Battery Line by Compass Marine How To – PBase.com, accessed December 6, 2025, https://pbase.com/mainecruising/image/164698591
Trojan Battery – T‑105 6V 225Ah (C20) 1200 Cycles 2‑4 Weeks Ship Time – Solar Kit Depot, accessed December 6, 2025, https://solarkitdepot.com/en-us/products/trojan-battery-t-105
Trojan T105‑AES 6V Battery – Batteries in Flash, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.batteriesinaflash.com/automotive-boat-utility/trojan-t105-aes-6v-battery
Trojan Battery – T105 AGM 6V 217Ah (C20) 1000 Cycles – Solar Kit Depot, accessed December 6, 2025, https://solarkitdepot.com/en-us/products/trojan-battery-t105-agm
Rolls Surrette S6 L16‑HC Deep Cycle Flooded 6 Volts 445 Amp‑hours – NAZ Solar Electric, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.solar-electric.com/rolls-surrette-s6-l16-hc-deep-cycle-battery.html
2024 How Much Do Golf Cart Batteries Cost – Manly Battery, accessed December 6, 2025, https://manlybattery.com/how-much-do-golf-cart-batteries-cost/
How Much Do Golf Cart Batteries Cost? Complete 2025 Pricing Guide – Vatrer Power, accessed December 6, 2025, https://www.vatrerpower.com/blogs/news/how-much-are-golf-cart-batteries
Winter Battery Storage & Self Discharge Characteristics – Marine How To, accessed December 6, 2025, https://marinehowto.com/winter-battery-storage-self-discharge-characteristics/